Skip navigation.
Home

Food for thought

Do social softwares such as Flikr and MySpace contribute to the glorification of self? NBC news covered this very topic last week in a story title “College students think they're so special: Study finds alarming rise in narcissism, self-centeredness in ‘Generation Me’” (http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/17349066/) I realize that this has little to do with social software use in libraries but it does make you think about the social impact that technology and the internet can have on society.

Looks like Yet More Media

Looks like Yet More Media Scaremongering to me. It's not as though we exactly lacked egocentrism and vainglory before the Web came around. (Most of us are Xers or older -- who's forgotten the "Me Generation"?)

Besides, the article ignores or downplays the n-way nature of much social software. This stuff isn't pure broadcast the way television is. If you think I'm a self-centered moron, you can go ahead and say so -- if not on my blog, on your own!

Great tie in with this news

Great tie in with this news story, i heard it too, along with another one about the negative effect of "overpraising" kids. I think there's loads of narcisstic twittering in the blogosphere and much of the Web2.0 world sadly reflects the societal apathy around us. But there's just as much use of Web 2.0 in a positive, engaging way (this class, the WorldChanging blog...for starters...) so I think we just keep sifting through the much to find the good stuff...

 

Shireen Deboo, Librarian

South Seattle Community College

I read this article in our

I read this article in our campus paper yesterday afternoon about student narcisism. I found the comments from the Psych instructors rather amusing, mainly because of their different views of the students.

One says: "I've talked with instructors who have been teaching a while," ..."We have mentioned the apparent trend of students feeling higher levels of entitlement for various aspects of the college enterprise." ... "If an instructor doesn't comply with the student's request and they get angry, that anger is coming from a sense of entitlement where a student really believes they are entitled to get that exam even though no one else in the class is," Berneiri said. "The increasing irritation and hostility on students for not being accommodated is increasing."

And the other says: "The students here are pretty cool - I don't see a lot of emotional rises out of them too much. That's probably just the culture of the Northwest."

Wow, where does this link between anger and entitlement come from? Resenting change?

Oh, man. You've just hit

Oh, man. You've just hit one of my pet peeves. I have a rule about not letting people use any variation of "those kids".

I remember being at a library conference (only 3 years ago) where the keynote speaker's main message was that we needed to look out for "kids these days" because they are self obsessed (blogs), law-breaking (copyright), have no attention span (phones), and so on. He had his audience pegged, too. They were chuckling and gasping along about those crazy kids. The moral being that we needed to prepare ourselves because such people are going to be our main users. I was so annoyed that I loudly commented that they are also your coworkers. Yea, because I really feel good about being a librarian when my habits are institutionally mocked.

Anybody besides me remember

Anybody besides me remember the Michael Gorman "blog people" ruckus? Long story short, Mr. Gorman took a pretty good potshot at bloggers in Library Journal when he was president-elect of ALA. Librarian bloggers resented it.

Mr. Gorman came to my library school that spring, and I was tapped to give a presentation for him. I did so -- proudly sporting a button that said "One of the Blog People."

And they are going to be or

And they are going to be or are currently our supervisors...